Pensions · how-to guide

Pension drawdown vs annuity: how to compare them

How annuities and pension drawdown work, what annuity rates look like in November 2026, the risks of drawdown, how to mix both and where to get free guidance.

By the UKEO editorial team · Updated 13 November 2026 · 6 min read

Older couple on a bench looking across a field
Photo: jhenning via Pixabay

When you come to use a defined contribution pension (a pot built up from your own and your employer's payments), two of the main ways to turn it into income are an annuity and drawdown. An annuity buys certainty. Drawdown keeps flexibility, along with the risk that comes with it. You do not have to choose only one. This guide explains how each works, what annuity rates look like in November 2026, where drawdown can go wrong, and how to compare the two before you commit.

How an annuity works

An annuity is an income you buy from an insurance company with some or all of your pension pot. A lifetime annuity pays you for the rest of your life, however long that turns out to be. You can usually take up to 25% of the pot tax-free first and use the rest to buy the income. The income is taxed like a salary and added to your other income, such as the State Pension, as Which? explains.

You choose the shape of the income when you buy. The main options are:

  • Single or joint life. A joint-life annuity keeps paying a partner after you die, usually at a set percentage. It starts lower.
  • Level or escalating. Level payments stay the same, so inflation erodes them. Escalating payments rise each year but start lower, and Which? says they may take 15 to 20 years to overtake a level annuity.
  • Guarantee period or value protection. These pay something to your beneficiaries if you die early, in return for a lower income.
  • Enhanced. If you have a health or lifestyle condition that may shorten life expectancy, you could get a higher income. Which? puts the uplift at as much as 20 to 30%.
  • Fixed term. Some annuities pay for a set number of years, such as five or ten, then return a lump sum.

The key trade-off is permanence. Once the cancellation period has passed, a lifetime annuity usually cannot be undone, and the pot is no longer yours to invest or pass on.

What annuity rates look like now

Which? notes that rates for a healthy 65-year-old have stayed above 7% since 2022 and recently moved above 8%. On figures gathered by Which? on 9 November 2026, a healthy 65-year-old with £100,000 could get:

  • up to £8,198 a year from a single-life, level annuity, while the lowest quote was £6,703
  • up to £7,775 a year from a joint-life annuity paying half to a partner
  • around £5,721 a year to start from a joint-life annuity rising by 3% a year

At 70, the best single-life, level quote was £9,086. The gap of roughly £1,500 a year between the highest and lowest quotes at 65 shows why shopping around matters. Rates follow gilt yields and the Bank of England's base rate, so they can fall as well as rise.

More people are buying. The FCA recorded 100,144 annuity sales in the year to March 2026, up 13.2%. Drawdown is still far more common, with 401,137 plans entered, up 10.5%. Only 30.8% of pots accessed for the first time involved regulated advice.

How drawdown works

With drawdown, you can usually take up to 25% tax-free, within the lump sum allowance of £268,275 for most people, and leave the rest invested. You then take income when you choose, as MoneyHelper explains. Each withdrawal above the tax-free part is added to your income for that tax year.

You decide how the money is invested. You can pick funds yourself, use a provider's ready-made investment pathways, or pay a financial adviser. You keep options open: you can buy an annuity later, take the rest as cash, or leave it invested.

The risks of drawdown

Drawdown suits some people well, but the risks sit with you rather than an insurer. MoneyHelper highlights these:

  • Investment risk. Your pot can fall in value, so your income is not guaranteed.
  • Running out. Living longer than expected, taking too much in the early years or not adjusting after poor returns can leave you short later.
  • Charges. Provider and fund charges come out of the pot. They vary, so it is worth comparing them.
  • Tax. Large withdrawals in one tax year can push you into a higher band.
  • A lower contribution limit. Once you take taxable income, the money purchase annual allowance cuts what you can pay into defined contribution pensions with tax relief to £10,000 a year.

Protection also differs. The FSCS says annuities from UK-regulated insurers are generally protected at 100% with no upper limit if the insurer fails. For investments held in a personal pension such as a SIPP, cover is usually up to £85,000 if a firm fails. Neither covers ordinary falls in investment value. Be wary of anyone who contacts you out of the blue offering to manage or invest your drawdown pot: our guide to spotting pension scams sets out the warning signs.

Mixing both

You can combine options. Citizens Advice notes you can use different options at different times in retirement. Common combinations include:

  • using part of the pot to buy an annuity that, with your State Pension, covers essential bills, and keeping the rest in drawdown for flexible spending
  • starting in drawdown and buying an annuity later, since annuity rates generally rise with age because the insurer expects to pay for a shorter time

Your State Pension forms the base of any plan, so it helps to check your State Pension forecast first.

What happens when you die

With a joint-life, guaranteed or value-protected annuity, Which? says payments to beneficiaries are tax-free if you die before 75 and taxed at their usual rate if you die at 75 or older. A single-life annuity with no guarantee simply stops.

Money left in drawdown can usually pass on. If you die before 75, it is normally tax-free within the £1,073,100 lump sum and death benefit allowance; after 75 it is taxed as the beneficiary's income, according to MoneyHelper. From April 2027 most unused pensions will also count towards your estate for Inheritance Tax. Our guide to pensions and Inheritance Tax from 2027 explains the change.

How to compare the two, step by step

  1. Find your base income. Check your State Pension forecast and any defined benefit pensions.
  2. List essential spending. Housing, bills, food and insurance. This is the part many people want guaranteed.
  3. Get up-to-date pot values. Ask each provider whether the policy has special features, such as a guaranteed annuity rate, that you would lose by moving.
  4. Get annuity quotes on the open market. You do not have to buy from your pension provider. Give full health and lifestyle details, as they can raise your income.
  5. Compare drawdown charges and investment choices. Ask for the total yearly cost in pounds as well as percentages.
  6. Model the tax. Work out how withdrawals and annuity income would sit alongside your other income each tax year.
  7. Take free guidance. Book a Pension Wise appointment before you decide.

Free guidance from Pension Wise

Pension Wise is a free, impartial service from MoneyHelper for people aged 50 or over with a defined contribution pension, as Citizens Advice explains. You can book online or call 0800 011 3797, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. It explains your options but does not tell you what to do.

Next steps

Gather your pot values and State Pension forecast, get a few annuity quotes and ask your provider for its drawdown charges. Then compare them against your essential spending. If the sums are large or your situation is complicated, a regulated financial adviser can model both routes with you, and our pensions page explains how UK Experts Online can arrange an introduction, with no obligation.

Free tool · 1 min · no sign-up

Pension tax-free cash calculator

See your tax-free lump sum, and how to pay less tax on the rest.

Example: tax-free cash from a £250,000 pot£62,500
Try it now →

Ready to talk to an expert?

Lost track of old workplace pensions, or wondering how to take money from yours? We connect you with a regulated pension specialist who can review your options with you.

Start your pensions enquiry

Sources

  1. Annuity rates, Which?, 9 November 2026
  2. What is an annuity?, Which?, 1 July 2026
  3. What is flexible retirement income (pension drawdown)?, MoneyHelper, 13 November 2026
  4. Retirement income market data 2025/26, Financial Conduct Authority, 24 September 2026
  5. Pensions: what we cover, Financial Services Compensation Scheme, 13 November 2026
  6. What you can do with your pension pot, Citizens Advice, 1 July 2026

We check every figure and rule against official sources before publishing and update guides when things change. This guide explains how things work; it is not personal advice.